Walls are closed, and that single fact drives everything about this work. In an attic a contractor can see what is there. In a wall they have to work out what is in the cavity, how the framing is laid out, and how material is going to get in without tearing your house apart. The method usually matters more than the material.
Spray foam carries a reputation as the premium choice, and in certain assemblies it earns it. In others it is expensive, hard to reverse, and solving a problem you did not have. The useful conversation is about the specific assembly in front of you, not about which product wins in general. Ask a contractor to tell you where foam fits in your house and where it does not.
Wall work prices on access more than area. Filling a closed cavity means drilling, filling, and patching, and how much of that patching lands on finished interior surfaces versus exterior siding moves the number quickly. Material matters as well: loose fill, batt, and foam are not priced alike, and foam in a small awkward assembly is not priced like foam in an open one. Whether anything has to come out first, whether the framing is blocked in unusual ways, and how many separate assemblies are involved all add up. Ask for each assembly quoted on its own so you can decide what is worth doing.
No. It performs well in specific assemblies and is a poor fit in others, particularly where a wall needs to be able to dry or where a moisture source has not been resolved. It is also difficult to remove once installed. Treat a contractor who recommends it everywhere with the same skepticism as one who refuses to use it at all.
Usually. Loose material can be blown into closed cavities through small access holes made from inside or outside, then patched. Whether that fills the cavity completely depends on framing and blocking, and there are walls where the honest answer is that the result will be partial.
Because it is surrounded by unconditioned space on more sides than a normal room, and the knee walls, the floor over the garage, and the connecting attic areas are all easy to leave incomplete. It is also frequently at the end of a duct run, so insulation is often part of the answer and rarely all of it.
It depends what you want from it. If the goal is a comfortable room above or beside the garage, the assembly between the garage and that living space is what matters, and it is usually a better target than the garage's own exterior walls. Say what you want to change and let the contractor aim at it.
The attic is where most of your heat goes, which is why it is usually the first place a contractor looks. Older Utah homes often have coverage that has settled, thinned near the edges, or been pushed aside by past work.
Learn more →Insulation slows heat moving through materials. It does not stop air moving through gaps. Sealing the openings between your living space and the attic is a separate job, and doing it after the insulation goes down is far harder.
Learn more →The band where your floor framing meets the foundation gets skipped more often than any other part of the house. If your floors never feel warm and the furnace seems fine, this is worth having somebody crawl under and look at.
Learn more →Sometimes the old material has to come out first. Rodent damage, water staining from a roof leak, and smoke contamination are all reasons adding new insulation on top would bury a problem instead of solving it.
Learn more →Cold rooms, drafts, ice at the eaves, or an attic you have never been in. Any of it is a place to start.